Disclaimer: Some or all of the companies reported here may provide compensation to us, at no cost to our readers. This is how we keep our reporting free for readers. Compensation and detailed analysis are what determines how companies appear on this website.
Morton Grove Coins & Collectibles is a family-owned coin, bullion, and jewelry buying operation based at 9241 Waukegan Rd in Morton Grove, Illinois, serving collectors and sellers throughout Chicago's North Shore and northwest suburbs.
The shop buys and sells rare coins, currency, gold, silver, platinum, palladium, scrap gold, and jewelry, and it has built a customer base that includes people who drive in from well outside Cook County.
This review covers what the shop offers, how its pricing compares to current metals markets, what customers say about the buying and selling process, and where it fits among other Chicagoland coin dealers.
Take a moment to read our list and determine if Morton Grove Coins & Collectibles has what it takes to make the list this year!
Or
Get a FREE Gold Information Kit from our #1 recommendation, by clicking the button below:
Protect Your Savings from Inflation and Taxes!
Key Takeaways
- Morton Grove Coins & Collectibles has been BBB accredited since June 2017 and operates a walk-in storefront plus a monthly coin show presence.
- The shop buys gold, silver, platinum, palladium, scrap jewelry, and rare coins, with pricing tied to daily spot metals prices that have moved sharply in 2026.
- Owner David Fishman and staff are repeatedly named in customer reviews for transparent pricing and no-pressure appraisals, though the shop's online review footprint is smaller than some bigger-box competitors.
What the Shop Buys and Sells
Morton Grove Coins & Collectibles operates as both a retail storefront and a buying counter.
On the sell side, the shop deals in U.S. rare coins, world coins, proof and mint sets, BU rolls, paper currency (including national bank notes, silver certificates, and gold certificates), and bullion across gold, silver, platinum, and palladium.
On the buy side, they purchase scrap gold, dental gold, jewelry, coin collections, and currency from walk-in customers.
The inventory rotates weekly. Recent listings on the site have included graded coins from NGC, PCGS, ANACS, and CAC, ranging from a 19th-century Seated Liberty half dime to modern commemorative silver dollar sets.
That mix signals a shop that caters to both entry-level buyers picking up a single graded coin and serious collectors chasing specific dates or mint marks.
Here's a quick breakdown of the main categories:
| Category | Examples |
|---|---|
| Coins | Half-cents through dollar coins, gold coins, commemoratives, world coins |
| Bullion | Gold, silver, platinum, and palladium bars and rounds |
| Paper money | National bank notes, silver certificates, gold certificates |
| Buying services | Scrap gold, dental gold, jewelry, coin collections |
Shipping is free on orders over $99, and the shop offers nationwide shipping for bullion and coin purchases, not just local pickup.
Protect Your Savings from Inflation and Taxes!
Reputation and Customer Feedback
Morton Grove Coins & Collectibles has been accredited with the Better Business Bureau since June 20, 2017. On Yelp, the business shows roughly 67 reviews as of mid-2026, with recurring mentions of fair pricing on both buying and selling transactions.
One reviewer wrote that they never had issues with the shop's prices in either direction, and another described the staff explaining the difference between bars, rounds, and collector coins to a first-time buyer's son, even letting him hold a 100-ounce silver bar during the visit.
Testimonials published on the company's own site echo that pattern. Customers mention David Fishman by name, along with staff members Brad and Mark, and several describe the shop as a place they returned to after being turned away or lowballed elsewhere.
One reviewer said Morton Grove Coins held a specific currency note for them until they could pick it up, after calling several other shops with no luck.
The shop is a member of the American Numismatic Association (ANA), the Industry Council for Tangible Assets (ICTA), NGC's dealer network, the Central States Numismatic Society, and the Illinois Numismatic Association.
Those memberships don't guarantee a good transaction on their own, but they do indicate the business participates in the standard trade and certification bodies that most legitimate coin dealers belong to.
Where the shop is thinner is on Google review volume compared to larger regional chains. Prospective sellers with high-value collections should still get a second opinion or a competing quote, which is standard advice for any precious metals transaction regardless of dealer reputation.
Pricing Context: What Gold and Silver Are Doing Right Now
Pricing at any coin and bullion shop tracks the daily spot market, and 2026 has been an unusually active year for both metals. As of early August 2026, gold spot price has been trading in the $4,030 to $4,130 per ounce range, after peaking at an all-time high of $5,597.23 on January 29, 2026, according to Forbes Advisor.
Silver has been trading between roughly $56 and $60 per ounce over the same window, down from its own all-time nominal high of $121.67 set the same day gold peaked in January, per data from APMEX and SD Bullion.
That means silver has pulled back sharply from its January spike but remains up more than 40% year over year, and gold remains well above the $4,000 threshold it crossed earlier in 2026.
The gold-to-silver ratio, a common gauge of relative value between the two metals, has been sitting in the high 60s to low 70s recently, according to Trading Economics data from early August 2026.
A wider ratio like that typically signals silver is comparatively undervalued against gold by historical standards.
For sellers, this matters directly. A shop buying scrap gold or silver jewelry should be quoting a percentage of that day's spot price, weighed in front of the customer, with the math shown before a final cash offer.
Multiple Morton Grove Coins reviews specifically mention this: staff weighing materials on the spot, stating the current spot price out loud, and calculating the payout in view of the customer rather than behind a counter.
That's a meaningful detail given how volatile spot prices have been this year. A quote that's a week old could already be off by 5% or more in either direction.
Location and Service Area
The storefront sits in Morton Grove, IL 60053, roughly 15 miles northwest of downtown Chicago. The shop lists service to a wide swath of the North Shore and northwest suburbs, including:
- Skokie, Niles, Park Ridge, and Evanston
- Glenview, Northbrook, and Wilmette
- Des Plaines, Rosemont, and Elk Grove Village
- Schaumburg, Arlington Heights, and Palatine
- Cicero, Oak Park, and Oak Lawn
- Cook County generally
Given the free shipping threshold and nationwide bullion shipping, customers outside that radius can still buy from the shop online, though selling in person requires a visit to the physical location.
Protect Your Savings from Inflation and Taxes!
Pros and Cons
Pros:
- Transparent, weigh-in-front-of-you pricing tied to daily spot prices
- Wide product range spanning coins, currency, and bullion in one location
- Long-standing BBB accreditation and multiple trade association memberships
- Free shipping over $99 and nationwide bullion shipping
- Family-owned with named staff customers can return to
Cons:
- Smaller online review volume than larger regional competitors
- No published price list, so quotes require a call or visit
- Physical selling limited to the Morton Grove storefront or coin shows
How It Compares to Other Chicagoland Dealers
Chicagoland has no shortage of coin shops, from Niles Coin Shop a few miles away to larger operations in Elmwood Park and Downers Grove.
What separates Morton Grove Coins & Collectibles in customer feedback isn't inventory size, it's the consistency of the buying process: spot price disclosed, materials weighed openly, and a cash offer on the spot rather than a mail-in appraisal with a delayed payout.
For sellers who want speed and transparency over the absolute highest possible bid, that process matters more than a marginal price difference.
Conclusion
Morton Grove Coins & Collectibles is a legitimate, BBB-accredited dealer with a decade-plus track record and consistent praise for fair, transparent pricing during a year when gold and silver prices have swung wildly.
Sellers with significant collections should still shop a quote or two elsewhere, but for most coin, currency, and bullion transactions in the Chicago North Shore area, it's a solid option.
