Disclaimer: Some or all of the companies reported here may provide compensation to us, at no cost to our readers. This is how we keep our reporting free for readers. Compensation and detailed analysis are what determines how companies appear on this website.
At Nunemaker's Coin Shop in Mishawaka, IN, a family-run spot since 1962, sell gold jewelry or buy bullion for cash. Get live quotes there.
This review checks pros and cons. It shows if their fair deals give real value for precious metals.
Prior reading further, it is important to acknowledge that investing your savings is a not easy. When it comes to incorporating precious metals into your investment portfolio, how can you tell which companies are reliable?
After devoting extensive time and effort, we have conducted thorough research within the precious metals industry and compiled a selection of the most trustworthy companies.
This lets you to quickly compare the leading companies in this field and select the one that aligns with your specific requirements and investment objectives.
Or
Get a FREE Gold Information Kit from our #1 recommendation, by clicking the button below:
Protect Your Savings from Inflation and Taxes!
Key Takeaways:
- Nunemaker's Coin Shop stays family-run since 1962 in Mishawaka, IN. It buys and sells gold, silver bullion, certified coins, and currency at fair, live market prices.
- Pros include trusted local service, in-person quotes, and emphasis on fair dealing; ideal for precious metals enthusiasts seeking transparency.
- Overall worth it for Indiana residents wanting personalized, no-hassle precious metals transactions with decades of experience.
- Alan Nunemaker leads the family business.
- They build trust with clear practices.
- Locals near South Bend and Notre Dame trust them for bullion and collectibles.
BBB, Infogroup, and Foursquare reviews praise fair prices and service. They make the shop worth it for NW Indiana customers.
Locals love quick cash for scrap metals at market highs. Wait times stay short for nearby sellers.
- Reviews from JPS, Arthur Knight, and Leady's Collectibles highlight honest deals.
- Shop earns trust for silver and gold bullion.
Pros and Cons Overview
Nunemaker's Coin Shop stands out for its fair dealing and live market pricing on gold and silver since 1962. Its in-person focus limits remote access.
This family business in Mishawaka, IN caters to locals seeking cash for old or broken jewelry, certified coins, and scrap metals without the need for shipping.
| Aspect | Pros | Cons |
|---|---|---|
| Pricing | Live prices, cash for 10k-24k gold, silver dollars, and bullion during highs | Prices fluctuate with market wait times during peak demand |
| Trust | Family-run since 1962, strong BBB profiles, Infogroup, Foursquare reviews for fair dealings | Limited online presence beyond local reviews |
| Location | Convenient for South Bend, Notre Dame, Mishawaka locals with in-person quotes | In-person only, no mail service mentioned, requires travel |
| Services | Handles old, broken, unused jewelry, dental scrap, certified coins, collectibles | No remote options for out-of-area customers |
| Experience | Alan Nunemaker's expertise in precious metals and scrap evaluation | Potential wait times for evaluations during busy periods |
Overall, Nunemaker's Coin Shop proves ideal for South Bend and Notre Dame locals seeking certified coins and fair cash prices on gold or silver items. Those nearby benefit from personalized service on scrap and bullion, outweighing the travel for non-locals.
Business Background
The shop lasts as a trusted spot. Customers sell old jewelry, broken pieces, and unused items like 10k, 14K gold, 18K gold, 21k, 22k, and 24k gold, as well as dental gold and bullion.
The family history and location build credibility for buyers and sellers alike. For a deep dive into what makes similar bullion dealers trustworthy, our in-depth review of Central Iowa Coin & Bullion breaks it down.
Family-Run Since 1962
Since opening in 1962, Nunemaker's Coin Shop has remained a family-run operation under Alan Nunemaker. It builds trust through generations of fair precious metals dealings.
Sellers get cash for old jewelry, broken chains, and unused rings in karats from 10k to 24k. Focus stays on in-person service for dental gold, certified coins, and silver dollars.
Location in Mishawaka, Indiana
Conveniently located in Mishawaka, IN, near South Bend and Notre Dame. It serves NW Indiana customers with easy in-person access.
Just a 5-10 minute drive from Notre Dame's campus. It draws students, locals, and visitors selling gold, silver, or scrap.
Ample parking and street access make quick drop-offs simple. Even during busy market highs.
Protect Your Savings from Inflation and Taxes!
Products and Services
Nunemaker's Coin Shop buys and sells gold and silver bullion, certified coins, U.S. and world currency. Plus scrap precious metals with live pricing.
Located in Mishawaka, IN, near South Bend and Notre Dame. This family business run by Alan Nunemaker serves collectors and investors.
They handle both buying and selling. Offering in-person quotes for items like old, broken, or unused jewelry in 10k to 24k gold, including dental pieces. Curious about how trusted local dealers like CMI Gold & Silver compare? Our in-depth review breaks it down.
Gold and Silver Bullion
Nunemaker's Coin Shop offers buying and selling of gold and silver bullion. Including popular silver dollars, at live market-based prices.
- Check current spot prices before visiting to time deals during market highs.
- Bring bullion for an instant cash quote, especially when prices peak.
This approach helps maximize returns on items like 1 oz silver eagles or gold bars.
Follow these best practices for the best experience:
- Check live prices first to hit market highs.
- Bring bullion for instant cash quote on the spot.
- Compare to recent highs and times for best deals.
- Ask about silver dollars availability in inventory.
- Verify purity for optimal fair price on all metals.
Example: Sell during market highs, like when silver hit $30 per ounce in 2021, for max value. Alan Nunemaker's expertise at Nunemaker's Coin Shop ensures accurate assessments for South Bend and Notre Dame area customers seeking quick transactions.
Certified Coins and Currency
Specializing in certified coins and both U.S. and world currency. Nunemaker's Coin Shop in Mishawaka, IN caters to collectors with authenticated precious metal pieces.
Graded slabs from PCGS or NGC guarantee quality for rare items. Customers bring holdings for in-person authentication.
| Item Type | Examples | Best For | Source Note |
|---|---|---|---|
| Certified Coins | Graded slabs, Morgan dollars | Collectors seeking rarities | PCGS/NGC authenticated |
| U.S. Currency | Dollars/notes, silver certificates | Investors in paper assets | Historical U.S. pieces |
| World Currency | Global rarities, pre-euro notes | Diversifiers expanding sets | International authenticated |
Actionable tip: Visit for hands-on verification rather than mailing delicate items. This family business emphasizes unique certified pieces over bulk scrap, earning strong reviews.
Pricing and Quotes
Nunemaker's Coin Shop provides live market-based pricing and in-person quotes for gold, silver, and scrap. Like old, broken, or unused jewelry from 10k to 24k.
Operating since 1962 in Mishawaka, IN. This family business run by Alan Nunemaker bases every offer on current spot prices for precious metals.
Nunemaker's offers cash instantly after inspection, unlike online buyers who factor in shipping costs.
The entire visit typically takes 10-15 minutes for South Bend and Notre Dame area residents seeking quick payouts, depending on wait times.
Sellers often make a mistake by arriving during peak hours without checking market prices first. This leads to lower offers if prices dip.
Selling old jewelry mid-morning when gold hits daily highs often yields 5-10% more than evening sales. Related insight: Kitco Precious Metals: A Trusted Name in the Bullion Market explains how these live spot feeds from major exchanges work.
Customers bring scrap gold or silver in any condition.
Staff weigh, test purity, and calculate based on live feeds from major exchanges.
- Visit the Nunemaker's Coin Shop location in Mishawaka, IN, during business hours.
- Bring your items, such as dental gold, 14k/18k/21k/22k/24k jewelry, or scrap precious metals.
- Receive a live market quote on the spot, ensuring a fair price tied to current highs for 14K gold and 18K gold.
- Get cash instantly upon agreement, with no hidden fees.
- Avoid peak wait times by checking gold prices online beforehand and coming early.
This straightforward system sets Nunemaker's apart from competitors. Building trust through consistent coin shop practices.
Local sellers appreciate the no-nonsense approach for bulk scrap or estate jewelry from the South Bend region.