Disclaimer: Some or all of the companies reported here may provide compensation to us, at no cost to our readers. This is how we keep our reporting free for readers. Compensation and detailed analysis are what determines how companies appear on this website.
Considering rare coins from Lost Dutchman Rare Coins in Indianapolis? This family-run business since 1983 offers bullion, collectibles, free appraisals, and expert consulting-but is it a smart buy?
Our review dives into BBB Business Profiles, customer feedback, pricing, inventory reliability, and services to help collectors and investors decide if it's right for you. Always verify company information.
Prior reading further, it is important to acknowledge that investing your savings is a not easy. When it comes to incorporating precious metals into your investment portfolio, how can you tell which companies are reliable?
After devoting extensive time and effort, we have conducted thorough research within the precious metals industry and compiled a selection of the most trustworthy companies.
Take a moment to read our list and determine if Lost Dutchman Rare Coins has what it takes to make the list this year!
This lets you to quickly compare the leading companies in this field and select the one that aligns with your specific requirements and investment objectives.
Or
Get a FREE Gold Information Kit from our #1 recommendation, by clicking the button below:
Protect Your Savings from Inflation and Taxes!
Key Takeaways
Family-run since 1983 at 4983 N Franklin Rd in Indianapolis. Expert staff ensures trusted transactions for rare coins, bullion, and more.
Competitive prices on bullion and rare coins. Free appraisals and expert consulting add real value.
Customers love the wide inventory and expert staff. Positive reviews make it great for serious collectors.
Should You Buy From This Dealer?
Lost Dutchman Rare Coins started in 1983 in Indiana. It has BBB accreditation and a 5.0 rating from 74 reviews.
Only 1 complaint exists, and it got resolved. The business sits at 4983 N Franklin Rd.
Buyers praise clear grading on coins like the 1984-S Los Angeles Olympiad PCGS PR-66 DCAM. Toned Olympic examples sell for about $600.
Check BBB A+ status to verify trust. It holds accreditation as of July 5, 2024.
74 reviews show 73 positives. The business sorts stock by PCGS grades.
No unresolved complaints appear. Call 317-545-7650 for consultations.
Trust checklist:
- Confirm BBB A+ accreditation from July 5, 2024.
- Check 74 reviews with 73 positives.
- Note 1 resolved complaint, 0 outstanding.
These make Lost Dutchman Rare Coins highly reliable.
Pros and Cons Overview
Lost Dutchman Rare Coins shines with a perfect 5.0 BBB rating from 74 reviews. Free appraisals balance out minor issues.
Pros outweigh cons 5:1. Experts at Franklin Rd evaluate Olympic coins for free.
| Pros | Details | Cons | Details |
|---|---|---|---|
| BBB A+ accredited | 73/74 positive reviews, highest rated in Indiana | Single resolved BBB complaint | Quickly addressed, no repeat issues |
| Free in-office appraisals | No cost, expert staff for bullion and ancients | Physical location primary | 4983 N Franklin Rd, Indianapolis focus |
| Broad inventory | Bullion to ancient coins, 1984-S Olympiad stock | Focuses more on physical store than online | This Indiana dealer holds top-rated profiles. |
Lost Dutchman Rare Coins shines with strong accreditation and deep inventory. These factors draw repeat business.
One minor shipping delay got resolved fast. Local buyers love checking coins in person.
Data shows great value for rare coin fans.
What Makes Their Pricing Competitive?
Lost Dutchman Rare Coins keeps prices low. They source coins directly and use staff expertise.
Check their 1984-S Modern Commemorative Los Angeles Olympiad PCGS PR-66 DCAM at $600. This family business in Indianapolis runs since 1983.
They skip big firm overheads for dealer-level margins. Buyers get savings, like instant cart adds for the toned Olympic coin.
- eBay charges 20-30% more for similar coins.
- Lost Dutchman wins with accurate stock and direct access.
Curious about how other direct coin dealers like Wholesale Coins Direct compare? Lost Dutchman prices simply: market value minus markup. Buyers save big.
The 1984-S Olympiad coin's market value sits at $700-$800. They list it at $600 for 15-25% instant savings.
BBB gives them a 5.0 rating from 74 reviews. Just 1 complaint out of 73 positives.
- Call their Indiana or Franklin office.
- Trust builds through clear pricing.
Collectors win long-term with low costs. Lost Dutchman Rare Coins handles top stock well.
PCGS-graded toned coins deliver true value. Reviews praise info accuracy.
Their edge beats eBay options.
Bullion vs. Rare Coin Deals
Bullion sells fast at spot plus a small premium. Rare coins like the 1984-S Los Angeles Olympiad PCGS PR-66 DCAM at $600 grow over 10-15% yearly.
Lost Dutchman stocks both in Indianapolis. Bullion sits 2-5% over spot, rare coins add numismatic gains.
- Bullion fights inflation.
- Rare coins gain from condition rarity, or coins in top shape.
| Aspect | Bullion | Rare Coins | Example |
|---|---|---|---|
| Pricing | Spot + 2-5% | Graded premium | PCGS Olympic toned: $600. Silver eagle: spot + 3%. |
| Liquidity | Daily market | Auction cycles | Bullion: instant. Rare: 90-day sale. |
| Appreciation | Inflation hedge | Numismatic rarity | Bullion: 5% yearly. Rare: 12% growth. |
| Risk | Market volatility | Condition/grading | Bullion: spot drop. Rare: PCGS check. |
Experts suggest 60/40 allocation. Put 60% in bullion for stability, 40% in rare coins for growth.
Lost Dutchman stock fits this mix. Customer reviews build trust with top ratings.
- Few complaints.
- Check BBB or call for deal confidence.
Protect Your Savings from Inflation and Taxes!
Are Free Appraisals and Services Valuable?
Lost Dutchman offers free in-office appraisals. Save $100-300 per coin over private ones.
Staff valued at $50-150 check authenticity and worth fast. One collector got spot valuation for a 1984-S Los Angeles Olympiad PCGS PR-66 DCAM at $600.
Consulting avoids 20-30% overpays. PCGS says pro appraisals boost sale value 15-25%.
Serious Indianapolis hobbyists get big returns (one of our hidden gem reviews of local rare coin dealers shows similar value in professional evaluations).
The PCGS submission service at Lost Dutchman Rare Coins streamlines grading. It saves time and shipping costs.
Collectors verify coin conditions easily. High-demand items like Olympic toned coins sit ready to add to cart.
Free consulting comes bundled. It offers tips like spotting undervalued modern commemoratives from eBay trends.
Customer reviews praise accuracy. The company holds a 5.0 rating from 74 BBB profiles, with 73 positive and 1 neutral.
- Call 317-545-7650 to discuss your collection.
- Bring coins to Franklin Rd for evaluation.
- Get instant verbal or written valuation with market comps.
These steps keep things efficient. Collectors make informed decisions fast.
Top ratings and feedback prove reliability. Free services earn high marks.
How Reliable is Their Inventory and Staff Expertise?
Lost Dutchman Rare Coins boasts 40+ years of experience since 1983. Staff at 4983 N Franklin Rd authenticate and grade coins expertly.
They handle rarities like the 1984-S Los Angeles Olympiad PCGS PR-66 DCAM Olympic coin. PCGS slabs verify authenticity and condition.
PCGS reports show PR-66 DCAM rarity. Few examples exist, boosting value stability big time!
The Indianapolis spot stocks bullion, ancient coins, world coins, and paper money. It draws all kinds of collectors.
Family members oversee everything. They review pieces to avoid grading errors on ldrcoins.com, eBay, and other sites.
Staff know coins inside out from decades in numismatics. They verify toned Olympic coins priced near $600, ready to buy.
BBB Accreditation confirms solid practices. Customers love the transparency from Indiana phone chats.
Review sites show a 5.0 rating from 74 reviews. All but one are positive, with zero complaints.
Key Authentication Checklist
To verify reliability, use this straightforward checklist when evaluating Lost Dutchman Rare Coins Coin Dealers.
- Check PCGS slab security features against population reports.
- Ask staff about experience with coins like Olympic series.
- Get return policy (30 days) in writing first.
- Review BBB profiles for rating and complaints.
- Read eBay and site feedback on inventory quality.
- Confirm 40+ years of staff experience since 1983.
- Note family oversight and diverse stock.
What Do Customer Reviews Say?
LostDutchman Indiana Coin Dealers holds a perfect 5.0 BBB rating from 74 reviews. It has 73 five-star reviews and 1 resolved complaint.
This 99% positive rate beats the typical coin dealer average of 4.2-4.5 stars. Customers love the honest appraisals and fair prices at the Indianapolis shop.
Many call it the best coin shop in the area. One buyer said, "Best coin shop in Indianapolis. Knowledgeable staff helped with my 1984-S modern commemorative Los Angeles Olympiad PCGS PR-66 DCAM Olympic toned coin, priced fairly at around $600."
Customers praise the knowledgeable staff. They offer detailed info by phone or in-person at the Franklin location.
Buyers like clear eBay listings and direct sales.
Zero unresolved complaints build trust.
Check BBB profiles to verify accreditation. Sort reviews by recent dates like July 5, 2024 and Aug 28, 2014.
Look at reviewer history. Skip single-review accounts to ensure legitimacy.
Look for patterns in reviews about specific items like rare coins from Lost Dutchman. Positive comments on fair prices for PCGS-graded coins far outnumber negatives.
Buyers praise quick fixes to issues. The single complaint got resolved fast.
Overall, this high rating positions Lost Dutchman as a trusted choice in Indiana's competitive coin market, far exceeding average dealer performance.
Is Lost Dutchman Right for Your Collecting Goals?
Lost Dutchman fits bullion investors who want quick sales. It serves rare coin collectors and beginners with free appraisals.
This Indianapolis-based company offers products from modern commemoratives like the 1984-S Los Angeles Olympiad dollar in PCGS PR-66 DCAM to ancient world coins, all with toned finishes that appeal to diverse tastes.
Whether you focus on spot pricing for investors or PCGS submission services for advanced collectors, Lost Dutchman matches needs across levels.
Investors get spot pricing. Advanced collectors use PCGS submission services.
Beginners enjoy free appraisals on bullion. Everyone benefits from market trend advice and rare coin stock.
To determine fit, consider this decision matrix that outlines collector types, best products, key services, and reasons to choose Lost Dutchman.
| Collector Type | Best Products | Key Services | Why Lost Dutchman |
|---|---|---|---|
| Beginner | Bullion | Free appraisals | Easy start with verified coins and Indianapolis support |
| Investor | Spot pricing items | Consulting | Quick sales with real market prices and BBB trust |
| Advanced | Ancient/world coins | PCGS submission | Rare toned coins like 1984-S Olympiad dollar |
| Institutional | Large inventory | Expertise | Extensive stock, high ratings (5.0 from 74 reviews), Franklin location access |
Love BBB A+ accreditation and local know-how? Start with this simple self-check.
Match your goals to the table. Check eBay profiles for stock. Call to confirm details. Lost Dutchman fits collectors from bullion newbies to rare coin hunters.
Company History and Family Ownership
Lost Dutchman Rare Coins started in 1983. A family-owned business in Indianapolis serves three generations of collectors with steady trust and know-how.
Key facts stand out.
- Industry sees 25% staff turnover yearly per ANACS study. This hurts customer service.
- Lost Dutchman thrives for 40+ years. They build lasting client ties.
- Services grew to trades and appraisals. Family values stay strong.
The company beat tough times. It survived the 2008 recession with top service.
BBB gave it an A+ rating. The ldrcoins.com site lets you browse stock like the 1984-S Olympic toned coin for $600.
Family experts handle calls and visits at Franklin, Indiana. This builds real trust.
Customers love the stability. BBB shows 5.0 stars from 74 reviews. That means 73 positive and just 1 complaint. No issues left open.
It beats many eBay sellers. Shoppers praise exact stock info and easy cart adds. Worth exploring: Is Bellevue Rare Coins Worth It? In-Depth Review Check BBB and reviews to spot a solid dealer.
Full Range of Products Offered at ldrcoins.com and 4983 N Franklin Rd, Indianapolis, Indiana
Lost Dutchman stocks it all. From bullion to ancient rarities.
Standouts include the 1984-S Olympic commemorative. Beginners grab spot gold and silver. Pros chase graded U.S. coins like MS65 Morgan dollars.
- Ancient Roman denarii and Greek drachms (NGC/PCGS graded)
- World coins
- Error notes and silver certificates
eBay buyers rave about variety and accuracy.
Novices in Indianapolis start easy. Buy American Eagles at spot plus tiny markup.
For a detailed comparison, see our review of Minot Coin & Bullion, another dealer offering similar bullion and graded coins. Experts check graded rarities. Phone help picks U.S. or ancient coins. Reviews praise fast shipping and spot-on info.
Sort by new arrivals. Leave a review after buying. Rare Indian Head cents pair well with bullion. Lost Dutchman covers every level.
Top Picks: Coins, Bullion, and Beyond
Lost Dutchman goes beyond standard bullion. They specialize in graded collectibles like the rare 1984-S Los Angeles Olympiad PCGS PR-66 DCAM.
These pieces suit every budget. Major grading services include PCGS, NGC, and ANACS.
Buyers verify authenticity via BBB Business Profiles and eBay profiles. Beginners buy bullion at spot plus a small premium.
Advanced collectors seek toned $600 commemoratives or MS65+ Morgans. The BBB-rated store in Franklin, Indiana offers paper money errors and ancients.
Call for stock checks anytime.
| Category | Examples | Grading | Price Range |
|---|---|---|---|
| Bullion | American Eagle, Maple Leaf | Uncirculated/Spot | Spot + 2% to 5% |
| Commemoratives | 1984-S Olympic toned | PCGS PR-66 DCAM | $600 range |
| Ancients | Roman denarii, Greek drachms | NGC/PCGS | $200-$5,000 |
| U.S. Rare | Morgan dollars MS65+ | PCGS/NGC | $500-$10,000+ |
| Paper Money | Error notes, silver certificates | PMG | $100-$2,000 |
The table shows diverse stock from this top Coin Dealer in Indiana. Customer reviews average 5.0 from 74 ratings with only 1 complaint.
Collectors trust their modern pieces and rare U.S. coins. Sort by highest rated to shop with confidence.
Local pickup works from their Indiana spot. Check company accreditation for peace of mind.
Protect Your Savings from Inflation and Taxes!
Additional Services Breakdown
Lost Dutchman offers more than retail sales. Get free appraisals, expert consulting, and PCGS submission help.
These services add value for collectors. They verify authenticity and boost returns on rare coins.
Free in-office appraisals save $100+ with no strings attached. Test items like the 1984-S Olympic toned coin at $600.
Consulting covers portfolio strategy and market timing as of July 5, 2024. Experts draw from years in Indiana's coin scene.
Pick stocks with 5.0 star reviews from 74 ratings. BBB shows 73 positives, 1 neutral, and 0 complaints since Aug 28, 2014.
Visit 4983 N Franklin Rd. Call 317-545-7650 for phone consultations.
Submit to PCGS or NGC with bulk discounts. Buy, sell, or trade at competitive rates that beat eBay.
These services build trust and accreditation. Choose Lost Dutchman for verified coin deals.
Location and Access in Indianapolis Area
Lost Dutchman sits at 4983 N Franklin Rd, Indianapolis, IN.
Phone: (317-545-7650). Visit in person easily.
The spot lies 15 minutes from downtown Indy. Plenty of parking awaits.
Reach it from I-465 and US-69. Call ahead as hours vary.
Book appointments for appraisals. Skip long waits with personalized service.
Take IndyGo buses 4 or 86. Walk 0.3 miles from the stop.
Drive from downtown easily. Follow these steps:
- Head east on I-70.
- Exit at Franklin Road.
- Turn north. Arrive fast.
Check items like the 1984-S Los Angeles Olympiad coin in person. Priced at $600, it beats online photos.
Buyers love hands-on looks. This builds trust and spots flaws.
Verify right away. Outshines eBay for toning and details.
Appointment policy stands out. Book by phone for coins like Indiana commemoratives.
Customers love the BBB profile. It holds a 5.0 rating from 74 reviews.
- 73 five-star ratings
- Just 1 lower
- Top when sorted by reviews
No big complaints on service. Collectors build community here.
Ditch digital platforms. Visit, review, and browse in person.