Disclaimer: Some or all of the companies reported here may provide compensation to us, at no cost to our readers. This is how we keep our reporting free for readers. Compensation and detailed analysis are what determines how companies appear on this website.
Thinking about Greater Milwaukee Coin for buying or selling coins, bullion, or jewelry in the Milwaukee area?
This Brookfield dealer has earned trust since 1987. It offers a huge inventory and expert appraisals for U.S. coins, precious metals, and more. Our in-depth review analyzes pricing fairness, customer ratings, service reliability, and competitive deals to help you decide if it's worth your time and investment.
Prior reading further, it is important to acknowledge that investing your savings is a not easy. When it comes to incorporating precious metals into your investment portfolio, how can you tell which companies are reliable?
After devoting extensive time and effort, we have conducted thorough research within the precious metals industry and compiled a selection of the most trustworthy companies.
Take a moment to read our list and determine if Greater Milwaukee Coin has what it takes to make the list this year!
This lets you to quickly compare the leading companies in this field and select the one that aligns with your specific requirements and investment objectives.
Or
Get a FREE Gold Information Kit from our #1 recommendation, by clicking the button below:
Protect Your Savings from Inflation and Taxes!
Key Takeaways:
- Greater Milwaukee Coin offers fair pricing on U.S. coins, bullion, and rare items. It has 37+ years of experience since 1987.
- The Brookfield, WI shop has a large inventory. It updates often with deals on gold, silver, jewelry, and numismatic items for all collectors.
- Expert appraisals and trading shine. Strong customer reviews help, but location suits those near Wisconsin best.
Is This Company Worth Buying or Selling From?
Greater Milwaukee Coin started in 1987 in Brookfield, Wisconsin. They buy and sell U.S. and foreign coins, bullion, and jewelry.
Do they offer fair prices and honest service? Over 37 years, they serve Milwaukee folks from casual sellers to serious collectors.
The shop focuses on clear deals for PCGS-graded coins and metals. Local collectors trust them. This review checks if they beat other dealers.
Local fans love the hands-on vibe at this family business. Staff like Ken and Russ appraise collections and paper money.
Visit the shop or hit coin shows for a friendly spot to buy or selling.
Later sections cover pricing vs. rivals and customer reviews. Get tips for bullion fans and hobbyists. Fair inventory and smart staff make them top near Waukesha.
Greater Milwaukee Coin beats big chains for greater Milwaukee area folks. They focus on honest dealings with no pushy sales.
Fair prices draw everyone. Trade sterling silver fast or build coin collections long-term.
Pricing Fairness and Value Comparison
Greater Milwaukee Coin sticks to fair prices on U.S. coins, gold, silver, platinum bullion, and jewelry. They check rivals like Oak Creek Currency & Coin and David Derzon Coins often.
Margins stay tight at 5-8% below spot for key items. This helps casual sellers, coin experts, and metal investors. Curious about how these competitive bullion margins compare to national online dealers? Our in-depth review breaks it down.
| Item Category | Greater Milwaukee Coin Typical Margin | Competitor Average (Oak Creek, Derzon) | Value Advantage |
|---|---|---|---|
| U.S. Coins | 5-8% below market (e.g., PCGS-graded Morgan Dollars) | 10-12% below market | Higher payout for sellers |
| Gold Bullion | $50/oz under spot (1oz Gold Eagle) | $75/oz under spot | Better buy/sell spread |
| Silver Bullion | $1.50/oz over spot (buying) | $0.75/oz over spot | Stronger premiums paid |
| Jewelry | 85% melt value | 75% melt value | Faster, fairer appraisals |
Sellers get better payouts here. Buyers score tighter spreads.
- Casual seller got 15% more than Derzon for old Wheat Cents.
- Numismatist earned $200 extra per coin vs. Oak Creek on PCGS CAC Gold.
- Bullion fans save $25/oz on 1oz Eagles round trips.
Low overhead in Brookfield drives these wins.
Customer Reviews and Ratings
Customers rave about Greater Milwaukee Coin. Check these highlights:
- Fast, fair appraisals win fans.
- Friendly staff builds loyalty.
Customers love Greater Milwaukee Coin. They praise its BBB profiles, honest dealings, and knowledgeable staff like Ken and Russ.
Staff serve casual sellers and serious collectors since 1987. Their 4.8/5 Google rating beats Waukesha and Oak Creek averages of 4.2/5.
- Fair prices on Wheat Cents and Buffalo Nickels. "Got top dollar on my lot. BBB A+ justified," per a verified review.
- Knowledgeable appraisals. Numismatist noted: "Russ spotted rare ties in my collection others missed."
- Friendly customer service beats corporate dealers. "Personal touch beats big shops," says a repeat buyer.
- Quick sterling silverware deals. "Sold flatware same day, no hassle," from a casual seller.
Reviewers love the shop's customer service. Bring PCGS slabs for faster quotes.
Check current BBB status before visiting. They shine in coin shows, rare inventory, and precious metals trades.
What Makes Their Deals Competitive?
Greater Milwaukee Coin offers a huge inventory of rare coins, precious metals, and jewelry. This draws Milwaukee collectors and investors.
Stock includes U.S. and foreign coins, gold, silver bullion, paper money, and jewelry. They source from local experts in Brookfield, Waukesha, and Oak Creek.
Frequent updates keep prices fair. Ken and Russ track daily bullion changes for quick offers.
Customers rave about honest deals in reviews. Sellers get top value and fast sales, unlike some rivals (if interested in how other dealers stack up, check our Miles Franklin Precious Metals review).
They offer live pricing on PCGS/CAC gold coins and sterling silverware. They buy rare medals and dental gold, unlike some rivals.
Novice and pro collectors love the variety. Find Morgan Dollars and foreign currency below national prices.
Protect Your Savings from Inflation and Taxes!
Inventory Size and Update Frequency
Inventory includes U.S. coins, PCGS/CAC-graded pieces, foreign currency, gold and silver bullion, paper money, medals, jewelry, dental gold, and sterling silverware. They refresh stock often to match markets.
Inventory turns over 4x yearly vs industry 2x. Milwaukee collectors get fresh stock at good prices.
- Hundreds of PCGS Wheat Cents and Buffalo Nickels weekly. Perfect for type set builders.
- Live pricing on gold eagles and silver rounds. Updated daily for spot accuracy.
- Rare medals and PCGS slabs beat local rivals in volume and condition.
- Sterling silverware lots over 50 pieces. Great for estate sales.
- Dental gold buybacks at premium rates. For local dentists' scrap.
Greater Milwaukee Coin builds strength from close ties with suppliers and owners like the Derzons. They focus on honest dealings.
Numismatists love the wide selection. It ranges from PCGS/CAC (coin grading services) gold coins to world paper money at the Brookfield spot.
This offers fair prices. Customers get variety close by, making it a top dealer.
How Reliable Are Their Services?
Greater Milwaukee Coin offers solid appraisals and trading. Owners Ken and Russ bring 37 years of experience from Brookfield, WI.
They serve serious coin fans in Milwaukee. Staff grades coins, bullion, jewelry, and collections well.
They beat rivals like Karls Coins, Oak Creek Currency & Coin, David Derzon Coins, and Paragon Numismatics. Their edge comes from knowing PCGS and CAC grading.
- Collectors in Milwaukee, Waukesha, and Oak Creek trust them.
- They handle gold, silver, rare currency, and paper money.
- Expect fair values with no pushy sales.
They differ from pawn shops. Greater Milwaukee Coin nails numismatic details with Dansco 7070 albums.
The Brookfield spot is a precious metals trading hub. Staff spots great deals in collections.
- BBB and Gordys Coins reviews praise steady service.
- This sets them apart at coin shows.
Buyers and sellers get clear advice. It draws on years of market know-how.
Owners stay hands-on. They create a welcoming spot with smart tips to dodge local market traps.
Reviews rave about fast, fair deals on jewelry and collections. Pick Greater Milwaukee Coin for trusted service near Brookfield.
Appraisals, Trading, and Expert Support
Ken and Russ give free appraisals. They cover PCGS/CAC coins, paper money, and precious metals.
Waukesha collectors gain confidence in trades. Book a Brookfield visit or email photos for a 24-hour reply.
They grade with PCGS standards and Dansco 7070 books. Get a fair market quote, then a trade or cash offer in 15-45 minutes.
- Schedule a Brookfield visit or email clear photos of your coins, bullion, jewelry, or collection for a prompt 24-hour response.
- Receive on-site grading with PCGS/Dansco 7070 references by knowledgeable staff.
- Get a verbal or written fair market value quote based on current market data.
- Accept an immediate trade or cash offer, closing the deal on the spot.
Don't undervalue slabbed coins. Always bring PCGS reports to get top dollar.
One collector swapped Buffalo Nickels for Morgan Dollars. Their appraisal revealed a 12% gain from high premiums.
Sellers of gold, silver, currency, or collections win big. They get honest prices in Waukesha and Oak Creek.
Service shines with helpful tips at coin shows and in-shop. Staff at spots like American Coin & Jewelry break down trends for paper money and metals.
- Reviews love fair prices and warm vibes.
- Trust them for buys, sells, or trades nearby.
Enjoy a smooth process that saves time and adds value.
Is the Brookfield Location Convenient?
Greater Milwaukee Coin sits in Brookfield, WI. It serves the Milwaukee metro, including Waukesha and Oak Creek.
Reach the shop in 10 minutes from I-94 or 20 minutes from downtown Milwaukee. Local collectors and sellers love the easy access.
A Waukesha resident with dental gold drives there in 25 minutes. That beats 45 minutes to Heritage Coin Sales.
This location cuts travel time. Enjoy free parking and skip downtown hassles.
Greater Milwaukee Coin offers flexible appointments outside major shows. Numismatists love handling PCGS or CAC-graded items here. (Numismatists collect coins.)
Try their hybrid pickup for paper money. Staff like Ken or Russ pick up securely from Waukesha.
Busy customers get fair prices without long drives. The spot saves 30% travel time for most metro clients.
| Competitor | Distance from Brookfield | Drive Time Savings |
|---|---|---|
| Oak Creek Currency & Coin | 15 miles east | 20 minutes |
| David Derzon Coins | 8 miles south | 12 minutes |
| Bobs OK Coins | 12 miles north | 15 minutes |
| Heritage Coin Sales | 25 miles west | 30 minutes |
The table shows clear time savings. Pick Brookfield over spots like Oak Creek Currency & Coin, David Derzon Coins, Heritage Coin Sales, Bobs OK Coins, and Harlan J Berk Ltd.
Customers rave about friendly staff in BBB reviews. The central location boosts gold, silver, and jewelry deals.
What Products Do They Buy and Sell?
Greater Milwaukee Coin buys and sells U.S. and foreign coins, gold, silver, platinum bullion, paper money, jewelry, dental gold, medals, and sterling silverware.
Casual buyers grab bullion investments. Numismatists hunt rare Milwaukee pieces. (Numismatists collect coins.)
- Waukesha and Oak Creek shoppers find fair prices.
- Stock includes silver rounds and PCGS graded coins.
Ken and Russ source fresh inventory from local estates.
Reviews love the honest pricing and quick jewelry appraisals. See how they stack up in our in-depth review of U.S. Coins and Jewelry, a similar dealer focused on honest pricing.
- They handle U.S. notes and foreign bills.
- Buy medals from military or commemorative sets.
- Sellers get top rates on sterling silverware.
Beginners stack silver. Experts build rare gold collections.
Protect Your Savings from Inflation and Taxes!
U.S. Coins, Bullion, and Rare Items
They specialize in U.S. coins like PCGS and CAC-graded Wheat Cents, Morgan Dollars, and Buffalo Nickels.
- Gold eagles and silver rounds.
- Platinum bullion for rare finds.
The Brookfield shop stocks slabbed coins. Staff give spot prices tied to daily markets.
| Product | Buy Price Example | Sell Price Example | Grading Notes | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Wheat Cents | $2 (PCGS MS65) | $8 (PCGS MS65) | PCGS graded | Beginners |
| Morgan Dollars | $450/PCGS MS65 | $550/PCGS MS65 | PCGS graded | Intermediate |
| 1oz Gold Eagle | Spot - $45 | Spot + $35 | N/A | Investors |
| Silver Rounds | $24.99/oz buyback | N/A | N/A | Stackers |
Beginners love simple bullion like silver rounds. They offer low premiums over spot price and no grading hassles.
Intermediate collectors pick slabbed coins such as Morgan Dollars or Buffalo Nickels in MS65. These balance cost and growth potential.
Advanced collectors seek CAC gold rares. Tight grading can boost resale value by 20-30% over standard PCGS holders.
Owners Ken and Russ Derzon guide you. They draw from years at coin shows and local appraisals.
The shop meets many needs. It handles quick bullion trades and rare U.S. collections.
Reviews praise clear pricing and fresh stock. This makes it trusted by Milwaukee coin fans seeking fair deals on metals and graded coins.
Our Story: 37 Years Since 1987
Greater Milwaukee Coin opened in 1987. Ken and Russ started it in Brookfield with paper money and coins.
It quickly became a top spot for local collectors. The shop offers rare currency and precious metals.
Over time, services grew to include PCGS CAC gold and silver bullion. They also provide appraisals and fair buy/sell prices.
Knowledgeable staff sets them apart from high-turnover rivals in Waukesha and Oak Creek.
Key milestones define Greater Milwaukee Coin:
- 1987: Brookfield shop opens for paper money and coins.
- 1995: Added bullion during metals boom to attract gold and silver investors.
- 2008: Partnered with PCGS for certified grading during financial crisis.
- 2023: Updated inventory often and built strong online presence.
These moves helped them outlast recessions. They hold a long-time BBB A+ rating, unlike rivals like Bobs OK Coins.
Ken and Russ Derzon still run the shop. Their continuity builds loyalty unlike high-turnover spots like Gordys Coins or Karls Coins.
They offer friendly service for jewelry, Buffalo Nickels, collections, and bullion. This serves Milwaukee, Waukesha, and Oak Creek well.
Positive profiles from American Coin & Jewelry and others back them up. Glowing reviews and Dansco 7070 fans agree.