Disclaimer: Some or all of the companies reported here may provide compensation to us, at no cost to our readers. This is how we keep our reporting free for readers. Compensation and detailed analysis are what determines how companies appear on this website.
Charleston Coin Exchange is a family-run coin and precious metals dealer operating out of a physical storefront on Sam Rittenberg Boulevard in Charleston, South Carolina.
The business buys and sells gold, silver, platinum, and palladium bullion, rare US and world coins, paper money, and sterling silver jewelry, and it also pays cash for gold and other precious metals brought in by walk-in customers.
At Gold is Money 2 we look at what the company offers, who runs it, how customers rate their experience, and what to know before visiting or calling.
Prior reading further, it is important to acknowledge that investing your savings is a not easy. When it comes to incorporating precious metals into your investment portfolio, how can you tell which companies are reliable?
After devoting extensive time and effort, we have conducted thorough research within the precious metals industry and compiled a selection of the most trustworthy companies.
Take a moment to read our list and determine if Charleston Coin Exchange
has what it takes to make the list this year!
This lets you to quickly compare the leading companies in this field and select the one that aligns with your specific requirements and investment objectives.
Or
Get a FREE Gold Information Kit from our #1 recommendation, by clicking the button below:
Get the FREE Gold Kit smart investors are using to protect their retirement savings.
Key Takeaways:
- Charleston Coin Exchange is a brick-and-mortar dealer in Charleston, SC, run by Charlie and Jan Vaganis, with the founder citing 46 years as a full-time numismatist.
- The company holds a 4.6-star rating across 239 reviews on Birdeye and has been accredited with the Better Business Bureau since 2012.
- The business currently does not offer online shipping or precious metals IRA services, so transactions happen mostly in person or by phone.
Company Background
Charleston Coin Exchange describes itself as one of the country's leading dealers in numismatics, operating as a family business. According to BBB records, the company was founded in 2003 and became BBB accredited in 2012. The store lists Charlie Vaganis and Janice Vaganis as owners.
Charlie Vaganis was selected as one of PCGS's first graders, a credential the company references on its site to establish expertise in authenticating and valuing coins.
The company's website states the founder has spent significant time reviewing auction lots and evaluating other dealers' inventory, which it presents as the basis for the appraisal services offered in-store.
The business calls itself the largest dealership in South Carolina, though that claim comes from the company itself rather than an independent ranking.
What can be verified is the physical footprint: a single storefront location in Charleston, rather than a chain of branches across the state.
What They Sell
Charleston Coin Exchange carries a wide catalog split across a few main categories. Bullion products span gold, silver, platinum, and palladium, each broken down further into coins, bars, and rounds.
Within gold and silver coins specifically, the site organizes inventory by country of origin, including US, Australian, Austrian, British, Canadian, Chinese, Mexican, South African, and Niue issues for silver.
The numismatics section covers individual US coin types (half cents and cents, nickels, dimes, quarters, half dollars, dollars, and pre-1933 gold coins), along with commemoratives, colonial and territorial coins, patterns, and world coins.
There's also a bulk and common-date category for buyers who want lower-premium coins without the numismatic markup.
Paper money listings include US denominations, colonial notes, fractional currency, national bank notes, and Confederate currency. Beyond coins and paper, the store sells jewelry and lists a dedicated "What We Buy" page describing the categories of items it purchases from the public.
| Category | Subcategories Offered |
|---|---|
| Gold | Coins, bars, rounds, US and international coin origins |
| Silver | Coins, bars, rounds, US and international coin origins |
| Platinum | Coins, bars, rounds |
| Palladium | Coins, bars |
| Numismatics | US coin types by denomination, commemoratives, colonials, territorials, patterns, world coins, bulk/common date |
| Paper Money | US denominations, colonial, fractional, national bank notes, Confederate |
| Jewelry | Sterling silver and other jewelry pieces |
The homepage also displays live spot prices for gold, silver, platinum, and palladium, updated with the change from the prior price point.
This gives visitors a quick reference before calling or visiting, though actual buy and sell prices at the counter will differ from spot based on premiums and the dealer's own margins.
Protect Your Savings from Inflation and Taxes!
Selling to Charleston Coin Exchange
For people looking to sell rather than buy, the company runs a cash-for-gold service alongside general coin and jewelry buying.
The site advertises free verbal appraisals, meaning a customer can bring in an item and get a spoken estimate of value without committing to a sale.
This is common practice among local coin shops and lets sellers gauge whether they want to proceed before any paperwork or formal offer.
Because Charleston Coin Exchange operates from one physical location and does not currently offer shipping, selling to them in practice means visiting the store or at minimum calling ahead.
The site explicitly states shipping is not being offered at this time, and it directs online inquiries to an email address with a stated 48-hour response window.
That's a meaningful limitation for anyone outside the Charleston area who wants to sell a collection without traveling.
Reputation and Customer Reviews
Review data on Charleston Coin Exchange is mixed in terms of coverage but generally positive where it exists.
Birdeye aggregates 239 reviews for the business at a 4.6-star average, with recurring mentions of the owners Charlie and Jan being knowledgeable and offering fair prices.
Yelp lists a smaller sample, 16 reviews, with similar praise for the staff's knowledge and friendliness during jewelry and coin appraisals.
Multiple reviewers describe repeat visits and specifically call out the owners by name, which suggests a consistent, personal customer experience rather than one driven by rotating staff.
One gap worth flagging: as of early 2026, an independent review roundup from Better Bullion noted the company was absent from some major third-party review platforms like Trustpilot and the Business Consumer Alliance, despite its BBB accreditation.
That same review confirmed Charleston Coin Exchange as a legitimate, physically operating dealer, while noting it does not appear to offer precious metals IRA services, since there's no mention of an IRA custodian partnership on the site.
The company's site also carries a notable warning at the top of its homepage, alerting visitors to scammers in South Africa and Malaysia impersonating the business.
This kind of impersonation scam isn't unique to Charleston Coin Exchange. It happens across the coin dealing and gold buying industry, where scammers copy a legitimate business's name and branding to solicit payments from unsuspecting buyers overseas.
The warning itself is a reasonable step, and it signals the real business operates only out of South Carolina.
Credentials and Industry Affiliations
Charleston Coin Exchange displays logos for NGC, PCGS, PMG, and the American Numismatic Association on its site, indicating familiarity with and use of the major third-party grading and authentication services in the coin industry.
PCGS and NGC in particular are the two dominant coin grading companies in the US, and a dealer's working relationship with them matters for customers buying or selling graded, certified coins.
The BBB logo appears as well, consistent with the accreditation on record since 2012.
Store Details
Here's what to know if you're planning to visit or contact the business directly:
- Address: 2022 Sam Rittenberg Blvd, Suite 102, Charleston, SC 29407
- Phone: 843-637-3304
- Hours: Monday through Thursday, 9:30 a.m. to 2:30 p.m.; some Fridays, 9:30 a.m. to 2:00 p.m.; closed Saturday and Sunday
- Email: info@charlestoncoins.com, with a stated 48-hour response window
- Shipping: not currently offered
- Social: active Facebook and Instagram accounts under Charleston Coin Exchange
The limited weekly hours are worth noting. With no Friday afternoon, no weekend hours, and a roughly five-hour daily window Monday through Thursday, planning a visit takes a bit more coordination than a typical retail business.
Calling ahead, which the company itself recommends on its site, is the safer move before making the trip.
Protect Your Savings from Inflation and Taxes!
Where It Stands Out and Where It Falls Short
The strongest points in Charleston Coin Exchange's favor are the founder's grading background, the long operating history dating to 2003, the BBB accreditation since 2012, and a review pattern that consistently names the owners and describes fair pricing.
For someone in the Charleston area who wants to sell coins, bullion, or jewelry in person and get a straightforward appraisal, that combination is a reasonable basis for trust.
The limitations are structural rather than reputational. No shipping means out-of-town sellers can't easily use the service. No IRA custodian relationship means it's not a fit for anyone building a precious metals retirement account.
And the narrow store hours require more planning than a typical retail purchase. None of these are red flags, but they do narrow who the business is actually useful for.
Conclusion
Charleston Coin Exchange is a long-running, family-operated coin shop with real credentials behind its founder and consistently positive local reviews.
It works best for Charleston-area buyers and sellers who want an in-person transaction rather than an online or mail-in service.
